Continued Drop In Prices

Happy Friday!

WTI crude is looking to close lower for a third straight week.  The growing world supply surplus conversation is winning over the usual geopolitical Gulf headlines. Here is what drove the market this week.

Monday, crude price collapsed after weak economic data out of China spooked traders. China has started restocking oil inventories at a pace not seen since March.  Even with its refinery throughput dropping, inventories of gas and diesel are building as well. The situation in Chinas plays well into the world surplus narrative for 2027.  The IEA now believes the world could even see an oil surplus by year-end. Gulf flows are still running close to full speed, even though Iran keeps attacking ships.  Iran also struck Bahrain for the first time in a month, putting the current ceasefire at risk. Wall Street is turning bearish too.  Some banks now calling for WTI to average $78 a barrel and fall to $70 by the end of 2027. At home, the national diesel average dropped below $6 a gallon for the first time since September.  Energy traders are hopeful that cheaper energy could help cool inflation.  Although the 10-year Treasury jumped back above 5% on bets that inflation stays sticky through year-end.

Tuesday, oil rose as escalating conflicts in Ukraine and between Saudi Arabia and the Houthis took over the headlines. Ukraine struck the bridge connecting Crimea to Russia for the second time in two days.  This was the first strike on the bridge in years.  The damage cuts off supply routes into Crimea. Saudi Arabia’s offensive into Yemen failed to gain ground last week.  On the supply side, the US Strategic Petroleum Reserve fell to another record low, but the bearish case still remains.  Also, US shale companies have been unwinding their hedges, betting that their strong balance sheets and production efficiencies are a better path forward than locking in low prices. Supertanker rates, which spiked to insane highs in October, have plunged more than 60% so far in November.

Wednesday, crude dropped more than a dollar a barrel after a very bearish EIA report showed solid builds across crude and refined products, along with US demand continuing to soften into year-end. That drop in price came despite overnight fighting picking back up in the Gulf.  Iran struck US military sites in Kuwait, the US hit back at Iran’s Qeshm Island in the strait, and the Houthis launched drones at Saudi Arabia’s East-West pipeline. Even with all that geopolitical noise, traders blinked. Trump met with Xi in China Wednesday and with Putin added to the meeting Thursday.  The market started pricing in hopes of better relations and a possible structure for ending the Ukraine war.

Thursday, crude rebounded as conflict fears took the spotlight back from the surplus story. Two more tankers hit naval mines and exploded in Hormuz overnight, and the Houthis struck Riyadh. Saudi Arabia said it’s now preparing for a conflict with the Houthis that could last into 2027, turning its East-West pipeline into a wildcard instead of the current Gulf supply relief valve. Trump’s meeting with Xi and Putin came and went without much to show for it, given how far apart they remain on major issues. The Gulf attacks are also hurting China, which has been buying more crude to refine and resell given attractive crack spreads.  Even so, the broader surplus story for 2027 is still intact. At home, the national gas price average hit its lowest level in eight months heading into the holiday travel season.  However, even with energy prices easing, the Fed is still expected to raise rates in December which should add more downward pressure on crude heading into 2027.

Friday, crude looked to close lower for a third straight week. Prices spent the week pulled between geopolitics and supply and demand, and supply and demand won out.  The current fact is that even with regular attacks on ships in Hormuz, oil is still moving around the globe at a steady pace.  In addition, flattening winter demand is adding to the surplus case gaining traction. The Houthis escalated again overnight, striking Saudi Arabia’s tallest building to send a message.  Although the conflict is still expected to stay contained to a small region in Yemen and Saudi Arabia. Russia started rationing refined products again Friday for the first time in a month as Ukraine’s continued strikes on pipelines and refineries keep squeezing Russian energy.  Even though China wants to buy more Russian oil, Russia’s logistics still can’t keep up with Chinese demand. The Trump-Xi-Putin meeting ended up being something of a nothing-burger.  Although China did pledge to add more fuel supply to the global market.  However, the market is taking the promise with a healthy dose of skepticism given China’s track record on similar pledges.

The Chicago spot market was unusually quiet this week, for the first time in months, with gasoline and diesel trading in step with crude. However, diesel basis in Chicago has further widened the spread against the Group.  So I believe we’re looking at some of the lowest diesel prices in months.  Retail diesel should keep drifting lower at this pace.  Although I don’t expect the bottom to fall out given how low basis already is sitting.  Therefore, a 20-30 cent jump in Chicago diesel basis wouldn’t be a surprise and is waiting in the background. Gasoline inventories have been tight in Wisconsin this past week, but we expect that to improve early next week heading into the holidays.  Gas prices should keep dropping slowly as well down to levels we haven’t seen since June.

Propane was also quiet this week.  Again, a welcome change after the runup of the past three weeks.  Prices relaxed and retail ticked down a bit. Normal, colder weather looks to finally arrive next week, which should get inventories moving again.  Total national inventories of propane remain in good shape ahead of the 5-year average.  However, the Midwest inventories are still running below its 5-year average.  But with a warmer winter still in the forecast, that gap may not end up mattering much.

As always, if you have any questions please feel free to give us a call. Have a great weekend!

Best regards,
Jon Crawford

Sources: Bloomberg, Reuters, Wall Street Journal

Posted in Uncategorized and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , .