Happy Friday!
WTI crude fell for a second straight week, dropping back to levels last seen in August as declining war fears and soft economic data pulled prices lower. Here is what drove the market this week.
Monday, oil fell $3 a barrel as Trump again said he doesn’t see attacking Iran, and Iran was rumored to have offered new concessions compared to its last proposal. Ship traffic kept flowing through Hormuz even though vessels are still being targeted. The entire Gulf region remains unstable, with the Houthis continuing their campaign against Saudi Arabia and hitting ARAMCO’s offices in Riyadh. The attack reinforced the Houthis’ intent on disrupting Saudi energy production. Russia also reported refined product shortages in at least six regions due to Ukrainian attacks. The shortage will likely complicate the Russia-US diesel import deal that is still not accepted by American oil companies.
Tuesday, crude traded in a narrow range after days of steady declines, settling back around where it was in August. Qatar and Saudi Arabia, joined by other Gulf nations, urged Trump overnight not to reignite the war with Iran. In addition, Reuters reported that 71% of Americans now back legislation to end the conflict. As Russia and Ukraine begin talks of their own, Russia’s refining capacity has officially been cut by 30% this year. As I’ve been writing for a long time, damage to Russian refining infrastructure is limiting exports, which is keeping diesel prices elevated. Diesel prices won’t fully normalize until Russian diesel is back in the market. OPEC reported an extra 1.3 million barrels a day of production in October, putting the group back near 90% of its pre-war capacity. And strong Chinese economic data along with slower-than-expected inflation helped support crude from falling further. Although a strong dollar is still working against prices even as some start to predict a demand in crude oil for 2027.
Wednesday, crude rebounded as markets recovered from the early steep selloff. Iran announced that no nuclear material will leave the country under any peace deal. Unfortunately, Iran’s nuclear program is the centerpiece of any deal with the US. So as of Wednesday, the escalation risk is back on the table. More ships were attacked and hit mines overnight in Hormuz. The first Russian tanker carrying diesel bound for the US stopped short of delivery and is turning back. No US company is willing to take on the sanctions risk of accepting the shipment. Instead, oil companies are just hoping that the diesel shipment ends up in the market somewhere rather than staying on Russian soil. The US also announced crude production will hit another record by the end of 2026. This will be the third straight year of record output, supporting that the US remains the biggest player in world oil production.
Thursday, crude opened lower after home building hit a 16-year low due to high interest rates, with potentially higher rates to come. Crude price reversed after Trump said a deal with Iran doesn’t actually need to happen. Even with more oil in the world market, which includes a surprise output increase from Russia in October and an EIA report showing builds across all petroleum categories, crude price moved higher purely on the renewed chance of conflict with Iran. Ships kept getting attacked in Hormuz, and a new front opened in the Black Sea where Russia has started attacking ships bound for Europe. The strikes from Russia are starting to disrupt goods imports into Europe and are putting NATO in a gray area over possible retaliation of some sort against Russia.
Friday, crude looks to close lower for the second straight week as soft economic data, inventory builds, and bets on an Iran stalemate took center stage. Fundamentals remain bearish, though I’d expect crude to take a bit of a breather here while the market sorts out “risk on” versus “risk off” with Iran. Trump said Friday he’ll likely extend the Jones Act waiver, which helps refiners move crude and refined products port to port more cheaply and should help keep a lid on prices at home. US producer prices rose another 0.3% in October, pushing the year-over-year rate to 6.5%. That is the highest rate since 2022. The data adds more support on the bet for a Fed rate hike in December. A stronger dollar helps push crude price lower, but a rate hike risks slowing the economy too. The situation could be a double whammy for falling crude prices. Some banks are now pricing in another $10 to $20 a barrel drop if the economy slows and the wars in Iran and Russia reach a settlement.
The Chicago spot market is finally back in line with normal basis fundamentals. The spot market is trading in lockstep with NYMEX again. Diesel prices have collapsed over the past two weeks and are starting to find a floor with crude sitting in the high $80s. I’d expect diesel to keep slowly retreating below $5.49/gallon. And if crude price holds, we could see the lowest diesel prices in months heading into year-end. Gasoline price has fallen too, just not as much as diesel. I still think we’ll see the lowest gasoline prices in months heading into the holidays. Lower gasoline prices would be welcomed relief for holiday travel. That said, there are so many moving pieces right now that volatility is still very much the name of the game. For now, enjoy the lower prices while they are here because higher prices could be right around the corner.
Propane prices followed crude oil prices lower and eased back a bit from their highs earlier in the month. Retail price fell back under $2/gallon and propane continues to trade in tandem with crude price. National propane inventories remain above the 5-year average but below where they were last year. And the Midwest inventories specifically are running more than 10% behind last year’s levels. If we get a genuinely cold winter, the Midwest could struggle logistically to move enough product around. And reliance on Canadian rail propane is front and center right now. Any disruption from Canada combined with cold weather could easily push Midwest propane back above $2/gallon.
As always, if you have any questions please feel free to give us a call. Have a great weekend!
Best regards,
Jon Crawford
Sources: Bloomberg, Reuters, Wall Street Journal